HookWatcher vs Hookdeck
By the HookWatcher team · Updated
The short version
Hookdeck's Event Gateway is production webhook infrastructure: queueing, transformations, filtering, deduplication, routing and rate control at volume. HookWatcher is a debugging and testing workspace that also forwards. Put Hookdeck in front of production services when you need an ingestion layer; use HookWatcher to see what a provider sends, reproduce failures on your machine and test how your handler behaves.
Side by side
| HookWatcher | Hookdeck | |
|---|---|---|
| Free tester without an account | Yes: an endpoint without an account keeps the last 100 requests for 2 days | Hookdeck Inspect: no account; captured requests are kept 3 days |
| Paid plans | Free, Developer, Pro, Team and Enterprise; limits and prices on pricing | Event Gateway: Developer $0 (10,000 events a month, 3-day retention), Team from $39 (7 days), Growth from $499 (30 days) per month, Enterprise custom |
| Deliver to localhost | hwcli listen delivers captured requests to localhost, byte for byte | hookdeck listen <port>; works without an account (a temporary guest account) |
| Public URL that returns your app's response | hwcli tunnel: a public HTTPS URL for a local app; the caller gets your app's response | No: Hookdeck's docs say a destination's response can't be returned to the caller |
| Automatic retries | Three attempts per delivery | Linear or exponential, up to 50 automatic retries; manual and bulk retries |
| Signature verification | Stripe and GitHub signatures verified against the captured bytes, plus test signatures for replays (paid plans) | Built in for many providers (GitHub, Shopify, Stripe and others) plus generic HMAC, Basic auth, API key and Standard Webhooks |
| Transformations, filters and deduplication | No | JavaScript transformations, filters and routing; best-effort deduplication within a window of up to 1 hour |
| Testing duplicate and out-of-order delivery | Replay, Modify & Replay, and Replay Lab (duplicates, delays, sequences; concurrent and burst on paid plans) | Not stated |
| Regression tests and CI | hwcli test run replays saved real webhooks and checks responses; JUnit output | hookdeck ci signs the CLI in for CI; no test runner stated |
Where Hookdeck does more
- An event gateway for production: queueing, delivery rate limits, fan-out, deduplication and at-least-once delivery.
- JavaScript transformations, filters and routing rules.
- Built-in signature verification for many more providers, alert integrations (Slack, PagerDuty and others on Team), an MCP server and a Terraform provider.
- Outpost, an open-source (Apache 2.0) service for sending webhooks.
Where HookWatcher does more
- Replay Lab, Debug Sessions and regression tests built from real deliveries.
- HTTPS tunnels that return your local app's response, next to captured-request delivery.
- Schema drift detection and field-by-field event diffs.
Compare with a real webhook
Switching from Hookdeck
| With Hookdeck | With HookWatcher |
|---|---|
| A Hookdeck source URL as the provider's webhook URL | A HookWatcher endpoint URL (playground, or sign in to keep it) |
hookdeck listen 3000 <source> | hwcli listen <endpoint> --to http://localhost:3000/webhooks |
| A connection to a production destination | Forwarding to that destination; Hookdeck stays the better fit if you need transformations or rate control |
| Retry a failed event | hwcli replay <request-id>, or Modify & Replay to change it first |
Frequently asked questions
Is HookWatcher a Hookdeck alternative?
For development and testing, yes: capture, local delivery, replay and tests. For production ingestion with queueing, transformations and rate control, no; Hookdeck's Event Gateway is built for that, and HookWatcher doesn't transform or rate-limit deliveries.
Can I use both?
Yes. They do different jobs: a gateway handles production traffic, a debugging tool helps while you build. Point a test webhook at HookWatcher to inspect and replay it, and keep production traffic on Hookdeck.
Sources
- Hookdeck
- Hookdeck pricing
- Hookdeck Inspect docs
- Hookdeck CLI docs
- Hookdeck retries
- Hookdeck authentication
- Hookdeck transformations
- Hookdeck deduplication
- Hookdeck sources (responses to the caller)
HookWatcher facts: features, pricing, documentation. Something out of date? Tell us.